The 50-Point Gap Threatening the Agency Business
Since 2015, costs per agency employee have risen by 60%, while productivity has grown by just 11%. Verena Gründel explores the widening gap threatening agency business models—and why AI alone won't solve it.
Rising Costs, Lagging Productivity: What’s Next?
The agency business model is eroding. This is illustrated by a rather shocking chart that IAB Europe Chief Analyst Daniel Knapp presented at DEX in Zurich. It shows:
- Costs per agency employee have risen by +60 percent (since 2015).
- Output per agency employee grew by +11%.
So there’s a 50% gap.
And this gap threatens the agency business model. Because the margin is shrinking. At some point, costs will exceed revenue, and the agency business will become unprofitable. We’ve long been observing this wave of consolidation both nationally and internationally. Most recently, WeCreate was sold to Mawave. Grabarz & Partner is taking over TBWA Germany. And so on.
Now everyone immediately thinks: productivity problem—AI will solve it. I believe: no. Because:
- … the potential of AI isn’t great enough for that: According to BCG’s 2026 AI Radar, cost savings in marketing amount to “only” 15–35% when AI applications, such as faster content production, are implemented correctly.
- … customers know this, too, and have already been using the AI argument to drive prices down even further.
The problem lies elsewhere: lawyers, tax advisors, IT service providers, management consultants—other service providers—are significantly better at selling their value, according to Daniel Knapp.
Why is that? The ROI of marketing services is difficult to measure. That’s why marketing is often the first target for budget cuts. Or to put it another way: price increases are almost impossible to implement.
So simply becoming more efficient won’t solve the problem. Something else is needed. This could involve new business models with different pricing structures.
Or better performance measurement that can finally prove the value of advertising.
How do you think agencies can escape this dilemma? Join the discussion on LinkedIn!
Don’t miss any important news from the world of digital marketing, both nationally and internationally! Subscribe to the new DMEXCO newsletter “Digital Digest” and receive the latest information directly in your mailbox every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday.